12 Recent Reads I’m On the Fence About (Some May Surprise You!)


Any reader will tell you that reading tastes vary widely–that there are as many tastes in books as there are colors in a paint store.

But still, there are SOME books that MANY, even MOST people seem to like, or at least to widely recommend. This is largely how I’ve come across the majority of books I’ve read this year—through recommendations made by other people, who liked these books so much that they were eager to pass them along.

But, for whatever reason or other, all twelve of these books, though highly recommended to me, didn’t *quite* make it into either my wow!-loved-this category (aka, 4 or 5 stars on Goodreads) or my wow!-that-was-truly-awful category (aka, 1 star on Goodreads, although a couple sure came in pretty close at only two and two and a half stars!).

Sometimes it was the writing style, sometimes it was the predictability, sometimes it was a trigger (such as an overload of terrible language and/or uncomfortable content), and sometimes it was just because the story didn’t grip me as much as I wanted it to, but for whatever reason, here are the 12 titles I’ve read lately that I’m distinctly on the fence about:

Title: The Year of Living Danishly: Uncovering the Secrets of the World’s Happiest Country
Author: Helen Russell
My Goodreads Rating: 3 stars (Overall Rating on Goodreads: 3.95)

I’m usually a sucker for books about people’s real-life year-long experiments to drastically change their life in some way, but this one fell flat for me. (In fact, the genre as a whole is starting to seem a little overdone, to be honest.) This particular one follows the author as she moves with her husband to Denmark when he lands a job working for Lego. Since Denmark is known as the happiest country in the world, Russell decides to focus each month on a different aspect of Danish life that contributes to their happiness and try to apply it to her own. Though parts of this were rather funny and I learned a lot about Danish culture, I actually came away wanting to try hygge-inspired happiness LESS. Overall, the book was enjoyable enough to press through (though it felt like it ran on too long), but not life-changing or inspiring to me in any way.

Title: A Circle of Quiet 
Author: Madeleine L’Engle
My Goodreads Rating: 3.5 stars (Overall Rating on Goodreads: 4.22)

Like many books that are based on journals or collections of assorted thoughts and stories, I either LOVED the section I was reading, or I didn’t care for it at all and became rather bored reading it. Since this particular Crosswicks Journal covered the period of L’Engle’s life when she had all her kids at home and was in the thick of mothering and writing and homemaking and meeting deadlines, I thought that there would be a lot more stories about balance, or about her thoughts on being a parent or a working homemaker. However, the journal was much more focused on writing and her own self-reflections as she experienced various things, both personal in her own life and in her outward community as a whole. I went into this expecting to be highlighting something every other page, but I was a bit disappointed when I only wanted to highlight maybe a dozen things total. There was a lot of this I could have done away with, but like I said, the sections that I was interested in were what made the book worth reading for me.

Title: The Ocean at the End of the Lane
Author: Neil Gaiman
My Goodreads Rating: 3 Stars (Overall Rating on Goodreads: 3.99)

Since I’d already read Gaiman’s The Graveyard Book (and quite liked it), as well as some of his other picture books, I knew to expect that anything written by him would be a bit, well, strange. (I’ve even called him the Tim Burton of the literary world). So it wasn’t the strangeness factor on this one that took the rating down for me–in fact, there wasn’t anything in particular that dragged this book down at all: it just simply wasn’t page-turning or mind-altering or highly-enjoyable enough to warrant the extra stars. I will grant that this one had some excellent quotes in it, though—passages that had I owned my own copy, I would have highlighted and dog-eared and read over and over.


Title: Anything is Possible
Author: Elizabeth Strout
My Goodreads Rating: 3 stars (Overall Rating on Goodreads: 3.87)

As a general rule of thumb, for a book to receive four or five stars from me, it must meet a few criteria: 1) it must be well-written and not be too predictable or full of cliches, 2) it must be a book that’s memorable and that I’m likely to look back on and think about for years to come, and 3) it must make me want to talk about it and recommend it to others. While this book was brilliantly written (Strout is a phenomenal writer, no doubt about that), this collection of loosely connected stories didn’t hold enough real substance for me to remember it much beyond the turning of the last page, and it definitely wasn’t the kind of book I’d be quick to want to talk about with someone, just because I felt like there wasn’t that much to say about it.

Title: Every Exquisite Thing 
Author: Matthew Quick
My Goodreads Rating: 2 stars (Overall Rating on Goodreads: 3.68)

This is the lowest-rated book in the pack, and it’s definitely bordering on flat-out dislike rather than just sitting on the fence. First, it must be noted that I loved Quick’s other novel (The Silver Linings Playbook), so I came into this one with high expectations for another homerun. It also didn’t help that I read David Arnold’s Mosquitoland just before this, which took the same kind of rebellious-teenager-seeks-to-find-her-authentic-self theme and did it well, whereas this one just made me hate the main character more and more by the end. Thanks to a cool sub-story in this one (about a book called The Bubblegum Reaper and the man who wrote it), this one might have scraped a third star, but a totally out-of-left-field event late in the book really took this one down for me—I just felt like the story kept on losing more and more traction as it kept going.

Title: Eleanor & Park
Author: Rainbow Rowell
My Goodreads Rating: 3.5 stars (Overall Rating on Goodreads: 4.11)

Oh man, this book–this one was particularly frustrating because story-wise, writing-wise, memorability-wise, this could have easily gotten 4 or 5 stars from me. But the thing that brought it down? SO. MUCH. LANGUAGE. And so much adult-themed stuff that I would never in a million years recommend it for a teenager, which is the target audience for this book. I know many writers feel like this kind of thematic content is “just how the world is for teenagers today,” but that’s just not true for all teens. I really wished this one would have been a lot cleaner–I don’t think anything in the story would have been lost.

Title: The Lost Book of the Grail 
Author: Charlie Lovett
My Goodreads Rating: 3.5 stars (Overall Rating on Goodreads: 3.86)

Overall, this was a fun mystery that was written rather well, though it seemed pretty slow at times. I was satisfied by how everything wrapped up (in fact, the ending made me like the book more), but the relationship between the two main characters didn’t intrigue me as much as it was supposed to, perhaps because it didn’t quite seem believable, but rather slightly forced. Basically, consider this a literary mystery with a dash of romance and history thrown in. It was a fun read, but I didn’t exactly consider it a page-turner until about the last third or so.


Title: When Dimple Met Rishi 
Author: Sandhya Menon
My Goodreads Rating: 3 stars (Overall Rating on Goodreads: 3.89)

Though this story of two teenagers being set up by their traditional Indian parents was kind of fun, I did find it fairly predictable and wasn’t really wowed by it (but then again, I’m not really one to like “romances,” really, especially ones that have such cheesy moments in them, like this one did). If you like YA romances, you’d probably like this one a lot more than I did. It was fairly clean as far as language and such went, though it did have some sexual references and one sexual scene (that were not terribly explicit). In summary, I’m not sorry I read this (as I found it mildly entertaining), but it’s not one I would really be excited to recommend, either.

Title: Edenbrooke
Author: Julianne Donaldson
My Goodreads Rating: 3.5 stars (Overall Goodreads Rating: 4.34)

And this is where I anger everyone who’s ever read this book (especially those in my neck of the woods, as people here are like, OBSESSED with this)—this one was just cute and fluffy for me, but never one that I’d actually want to read again. I found the story fairly predictable, and there were many moments throughout where I literally rolled my eyes at the main character, as she was just SO CLUELESS. All in all, it was not enough to convert me to liking romances any more than before (although, it must be noted, it was nice to read a totally clean romance for once!), but it was kind of a fun “candy” book to pass the time.


Title: At Home in the World 
Author: Tsh Oxenreider
My Goodreads Rating: 3.5 stars (Overall Rating on Goodreads: 4.27)

I wanted to be WOWED by this one so badly, especially because I adore Tsh’s blog The Art of Simple, but this one didn’t *quite* live up to my expectations. While I found her reflections on traveling with kids and on finding out more about herself and about the wider world to be spot-on, I felt like a little bit too much of this book read like an unedited daily log of events: “We traveled there. It was hot. We had jet lag. This was pretty.” Had the book tightened up its descriptions on the actual traveling and places visited a bit more, as well as thrown in some more reflections throughout (esp. near the beginning), I think I would have liked this one more. As it was, it was just in the middle for me.

Title: Traveling with Pomegranates
Authors: Sue Monk Kidd and Ann Kidd Taylor
My Goodreads Rating: 2.5 Stars (Overall Rating on Goodreads: 3.44)

This one barely scraped 2.5 stars for me, and the only reason it wasn’t at a solid 2-star rating is because I quite liked the last few chapters on the actual writing of the book itself. It might just be that I read this book at the wrong time in my life, or maybe that I went into it with the wrong expectations of what the book would be about, but this was not some delightful mother-daughter tale of travel and intrigue, but rather a long and drawn out string of self-absorbed reflections, with heavy descriptions of Greek architecture and myths thrown in. This one just really dragged, though it did have some nice thoughts thrown in here and there.


Title: The Art of Hearing Heartbeats 
Author: Jan-Philipp Sendker
My Goodreads Rating: 3.5 stars (Overall Rating on Goodreads: 3.98)

I finally joined a book club, and this was the first selection that I read for my first meeting. As I wrote on my Goodreads full review, this book was what I expected Love in the Time of Cholera to be like (but that it definitely, DEFINITELY wasn’t), so on that hand, I liked it–I liked the feeling of an exotic love story that stands the test of time and place and circumstance, and this novel just had such a sense of mystery about it that made it a really quick read. However, if I stop to think about the premise too long, the moral implications of the story REALLY start to bug me, and I also noticed several gaping plot holes that kept me from wanting to really recommend this one.

Were you surprised by my reaction to any of these? Which ones have you read? Let’s talk books!

For ten recent reads worth recommending for sure (aka, that I’m not on the fence about), click here.

13 Replies to “12 Recent Reads I’m On the Fence About (Some May Surprise You!)”

  1. okay, full disclosure – I usually skim through peoples reading lists to gauge whether or not I think we might actually have similar taste.. haha, but yay!! I found a few that I haven't read that you really made me want to read!! That might be one of my favorite things – finding a book or two that you're excited to read!


  2. and I'll probably still read Tsh book… and feel the same way.. but I'll want to read it myself anyway. But I might like it better because you've managed my expectations! =)


  3. I've read only one of these-Edenbrooke-and I gasped aloud at your review. 😉 I am one of the ones who loved the book, but I get why you didn't fall in love with it. A few of the books on this list have been on my TBR list for years, but I obviously haven't been overly excited to jump in. I always love hearing your thoughts on books!


  4. By all means, I hope you still read it! You'll notice that in each case, my rating on Goodreads was lower than the average rating, which means that most people liked ALL of these better than I did. So definitely worth still checking out!


  5. Ha ha, you gasped aloud…that made me chuckle. And like I said in my reply above, my ratings were lower than the average in every case, so you might still want to check some of these out anyway! Just let me know what you think of them when you're done 🙂


  6. Wow! so many books I've never heard of! haha. I am pretty picky about books – aka if I don't like it I don't finish it! lol.


  7. I loved Eleanor & Park, but you definitely make an excellent point!
    Great list – so interesting to hear what people think about books that have been hyped up to them 🙂


  8. People LOVE Elizabeth Strout, and I agree that her writing is amazing, but I just haven't loved any of her books.

    I was really surprised that When Dimple Met Rishi got such good buzz and reviews. I was SO BORED! with this book. I read 300 pages, felt like nothing was happening, and gave up on it.

    This is going to sound so, so snobby, but I don't get how people who enjoy good literature could ever enjoy Edenbrooke. Hold it up against Pride and Prejudice and there's just no comparison. I am pretty much the most snobby person in the world when it comes to period romances – I hate just about every modern adaptation or modern attempt to write a period drama. They so easily cross the line into cheesy, sappy, cliche, saccharine, etc.

    So, for the ones I've read, it looks like I agree with you on not being wowed. The only one I seemed to have enjoyed more than you did was Circle of Quiet. I came to that one with no expectations, so it was easy to be pleasantly surprised.


  9. I SO HATEEEEEE how much language is in books, especially YA books tailored to a younger audience. I'm always shocked by it. Sadly, I think 'bad language” is just going to become a norm … frustrates me so much. I did love Eleanor & Park though & wish some of it was toned down though.


  10. I JUST started Year of Living Danishly. I've been waiting for this to come up on my turn at the library forever. Now, I'm hoping I'm not disappointed based on your review.


  11. I love that you were honest about how these books fell flat for you even though others may love them. A few of these are on mu TBR list (Traveling With Pomegranates, Circle of Quiet, A Year if Living Danishly) so I really appreciated your reviews of them. I was interested in Eleanor & Park but now that I hear theres a lot of language and adult themes, I think I will skip it.

    Here are my recent reads: https://elle-alice.blogspot.ca/2017/07/july-book-reviews.html


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s